Appeals Court Rules Fired SpaceX Engineers Can Take Their Harassment Case to Court, Not Arbitration

A 2-1 Ninth Circuit ruling says eight fired SpaceX engineers can keep their sexual harassment and retaliation suit in court. SpaceX denies the claims.

In the news · By Ryan Stygar, Employment Attorney ·

The short version: On November 10, 2026, a divided federal appeals court ruled that SpaceX can't force eight former engineers' lawsuit into private arbitration. The engineers allege they were fired after circulating a letter criticizing Elon Musk's sexually charged social media posts, and SpaceX has denied the allegations. The ruling is about where the case is heard, not who is right.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, which covers California, decided Holland-Thielen v. SpaceX (No. 25-4811) on November 10 by a 2-1 vote (Leagle, court opinion; Gizmodo). Judge Michelle Friedland wrote the majority opinion, and Judge Eric Tung dissented, Gizmodo reports.

What do the engineers allege?

According to Reuters, the eight engineers "circulated a letter calling the billionaire a 'distraction and embarrassment'" and urged SpaceX executives to disavow sexually charged comments Musk had made on social media. They claim Musk ordered their firing, and their lawsuit says his conduct fostered a "pervasively sexist culture" at the company (Reuters via Insurance Journal).

The engineers filed suit in 2024, Reuters reports. According to the complaint as described by HR trade publication HCA, they brought claims for retaliatory termination, hostile work environment sexual harassment, and gender discrimination. The case started in California state court and was moved to federal court, where SpaceX asked a judge to send it to arbitration (HCA). A federal judge denied that request, and SpaceX appealed.

Musk is also named as a defendant (Leagle). These are allegations. No court has decided whether they are true.

What does SpaceX say?

Reuters reports that "SpaceX has denied the allegations" and that company spokespeople did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the ruling. Gizmodo says SpaceX didn't respond to its request either.

Laurie Burgess, a lawyer for the engineers, told Reuters they were "delighted" with the court's "well-reasoned" decision.

What did the court decide?

The fight was over a 2022 federal law, the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act of 2021 (Pub. L. 117-90, approved March 3, 2022). It lets a person alleging a "sexual harassment dispute" choose court instead of arbitration, even after signing an arbitration agreement (9 U.S.C. § 402(a)). The law defines that as "a dispute relating to conduct that is alleged to constitute sexual harassment under applicable Federal, Tribal, or State law" (Pub. L. 117-90, § 401(4)).

SpaceX argued the engineers had to show their harassment claims were strong enough to survive a motion to dismiss before the law kicked in, HCA reports. The majority disagreed. According to HCA's report on the opinion, the court read "allege" to mean "to assert something as true," and found that Congress "deliberately chose not to write that stricter standard into the statute." Gizmodo, quoting Courthouse News, reports that Judge Friedland wrote that "Congress could have easily drafted the EFAA" to require that kind of showing.

HCA also reports that the court treated the retaliation claims as part of the sexual harassment dispute and held that the exception covers the whole case, so all the claims stay in court.

What did the dissent say?

Judge Tung warned that the majority's test would let any claim that "so much as purports to allege" sexual harassment escape arbitration, according to Gizmodo. He would have required more detailed allegations before an employee could skip an arbitration agreement.

What happens next?

The case goes back to the trial court, where SpaceX can still fight the allegations. Gizmodo reports it isn't yet clear whether SpaceX will accept the ruling or ask the full Ninth Circuit to rehear it.

What this means for California workers

The Ninth Circuit's rulings bind federal courts in California, so this decision matters for anyone here who signed an arbitration agreement as a condition of getting hired. Under this ruling, if you allege sexual harassment under federal or state law, you don't have to prove your case is strong before you can choose court. And according to HCA's reading of the decision, a related claim (like being fired for complaining about harassment) can travel with it.

California law gives you plenty to allege. The Fair Employment and Housing Act makes it illegal to harass an employee, applicant, unpaid intern, volunteer, or contractor (Gov. Code § 12940(j)(1)). It's also illegal to fire or punish someone for opposing practices the law forbids (Gov. Code § 12940(h)), and "Sexually harassing conduct need not be motivated by sexual desire" (Gov. Code § 12940(j)(4)(C)).

Two cautions. First, the choice belongs to you: the federal law applies "at the election of" the person alleging the harassment (9 U.S.C. § 402(a)), and a judge decides whether it applies (9 U.S.C. § 402(b)). Second, this case is still moving, and SpaceX could seek further review. Our guide on forced arbitration and sexual harassment claims explains how the law works, and our guide on retaliation after reporting harassment covers what your employer can't do after you speak up.

Harassed at work?

You don't have to handle it alone. Tell us what happened, and we'll help you understand your options.

Get help now

This article is general information about California and federal law as of its date, not legal advice for your situation. Laws change, and the right move depends on your facts.

Get help now